Payday loans

Rod Dreher: Another whiny white guy on diversity

11/05/2009 6:00 am 6 comments

Richard Prince posted in his Journal-isms column a piece written by conservative columnist Rod Dreher about the issue of diversity. It seems that Dreher took umbrage to the National Association of Black Journalists taking National Public Radio to task for their lack of diversity in upper management.

I read the column you wrote on Belief.net, and had to fire off this response:

“I read the column you wrote on BeliefNet.com and all it does it express your utter ignorance of diversity this business.

“You wrote that you don’t care about ethnic diversity and that it really doesn’t matter. Well, it does matter. I can recall the atrocious column you wrote in a New York paper when Aaliyah died. Your characterization of this young woman as essentially being a nobody because you never heard of her spoke volumes. Yet when there was an outpouring of affection for this talented young lady from her fans, it clearly showed that there are people of color who are beloved in their community, even when whites like yourself are clueless. I was one of the folks who took to the airwaves on the Tom Joyner Morning Show and ripped you for the callous nature of what you wrote. Eight years later, you clearly recognized the utter ignorance when you wrote: “My 2001 Aaliyah column was mean, and I regret it.”

“I’m sure you had the same reaction when Selena died. We all saw white editors nationwide dismiss the importance of her death. I remember white editors at the Fort Worth Star-Telegram blowing off her death, saying it wasn’t worth sending reporters to the scene. It was only after we saw the amazing response did they discover something was larger. Oh, we sent a team of reporters. Why? Because I pushed them to ask our Hispanic staffers about Selena and her importance. I had never heard of her, but had the common sense to ask someone else. But had Garth Brooks or Brooks & Dunn been killed by the head of their fan club, that would have been called a no-brainer.

“For the record, NABJ doesn’t need you or Vivian Schiller telling us about recruitment. We do this EVERY DAY. We have always been on the front lines recruiting, training, re-training and advocating for our members. And in the 20 years I’ve been a member of NABJ (a student board member from 1989-1991 and currently secretary), I’ve personally witnessed ignorant media executives repeat the classic and ridiculous comment you made: they are just so hard to find.

“Then you have the audacity to tell a story of a poor colleague who searched near and far to find a Hispanic candidate, only to realize the oh-so-talented super Hispanic journalist was in such great demand? Give me a damn break! We hear that crap every day from people like you.

“Rod, since you are deaf, dumb and blind to diversity in our industry, why don’t you walk down the hall and go talk to some of your bosses at the Dallas Morning News, long a leader in diversity in the industry. Why don’t you have the courage to ask Bob Mong how he managed to hire talented journalists of color over the years. Maybe it’s because he didn’t sit in an office and diminish the number of talented minority journalists all around the country. Maybe he didn’t spend his time writing mindless columns without any real thought on how diversity is meaningless. Do you know what he did? He showed up at the conventions of NABJ, NAHJ, AAJA, and NAJA. He and others understood that their cities were changing, and they needed people who could report in a diverse Dallas and D/FW Metroplex. They didn’t whine about how hard it was. Only weak people looking for an excuse do that.

“Rod, if you have an ax to grind about diversity of thought on NPR, fine. Keep complaining so they can hire a conservative voice like yours. But if you’re going to choose to write about ethnic diversity and dismiss it as not important, learn to do what real reporters do, and that is gain the facts, and write from a position of knowledge and not ignorance.

NABJ will always be hire to fight for diversity. We’ve seen individuals like you write silly stuff before, and I’m sure there are other uninformed Rod Drehers waiting to write such nonsense again. But we will not lose the fire in our belly. We will not surrender. We will not abdicate the mission of our founders to demand a seat at the table and expand the management ranks with diverse talent, whether in the newsroom or in management

“I’ll simply leave you to ponder the remarks made by longtime CNN anchor Bernard Shaw, spoken at the NABJ national convention in 2007, when he accepted our lifetime achievement award: ‘Beyond this ballroom, tonight, white males – wake up. Globally, you are an island speck in an ocean of color. The reins of power will weaken and so will your grip – if you do not faithfully support our nation’s greatest strength, diversity.’”

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Sphere: Related Content

Related Posts
ROLAND S. MARTIN: It’s Time To Stop Being So Sensitive About Discussing Out-Of-Wedlock Children
By Roland S. Martin Editor-in-Chief RolandMartinReports.com Listen to any politician talk, and you'll quickly realize that there are so many crises in America ...
READ MORE
Perspective: At The Table Of Brotherhood, Discussing Differences And Gaining Understanding
In his famous "I Have a Dream" speech at the March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom on August 28, ...
READ MORE
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Props To NCAA For Banning Connecticut From March Madness
 By Roland S. MartinEditor-in-ChiefRolandMartinReports.comMarch Madness is usually a wild and crazy time on the campuses of the nation's big-time college ...
READ MORE
By Roland S. MartinMy political friends on the right always talk about small government, being fiscally responsible, and not burdening ...
READ MORE
Final Thoughts On Super Bowl-Twitter Controversy
By Roland S. Martin Based on several tweets I made on my Twitter feed on Super Bowl Sunday yesterday, I have ...
READ MORE
Roland Martin’s Statement Regarding The H&M David Beckham Ad
By Roland S. Martin Editor-in-Chief RolandMartinReports.com Fam, let me address the issue that some in the LGBT community have raised regarding some of ...
READ MORE
By Roland S. MartinEditor-in-ChiefRolandMartinReports.comIn the 1,257 GOP debates we've had to sit through, poverty and the poor has rarely come ...
READ MORE
By Roland S. MartinEditor-in-ChiefRolandMartinReports.comVery few things will make my skin crawl more than listening to someone totally misrepresent the famous ...
READ MORE
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Only Students Can Truly End Hazing
By Roland S. MartinEditor-in-ChiefRolandMartinReports.comIn November 2010, I watched HBO's "Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel" and saw the piece done on ...
READ MORE
By Roland S. MartinEditor-in-ChiefRolandMartinReports.comAll of the post-mortems on the CNBC Republican debate have focused on the sad but hilarious senior ...
READ MORE
ROLAND S. MARTIN: It’s Time To Stop Being
Perspective: At The Table Of Brotherhood, Discussing Differences
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Props To NCAA For Banning
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Today’s GOP Missouri Primary Is
Final Thoughts On Super Bowl-Twitter Controversy
Roland Martin’s Statement Regarding The H&M David Beckham
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Romney’s Campaign GPS Ignores The
ROLAND S. MARTIN: King’s ‘Dream’ Was A Radical
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Only Students Can Truly End
ROLAND S. MARTIN: GOP Debate Ignores Wall Street’s
  • P. L. Newkirk

    Very well stated and words that need expression. The attitude of Rod Dreher is mirrored in so many industries in America in the 21st century. Keep fighting the good fight in this front, Roland.

  • Kimberley Cornwell

    Well said. I hope that you send this to Mr. Dreher. It would be interesting to see if what his response might be.

  • audrey wynn

    Kudos to you Roland for your response. When I read Dreher’s comments I thought how many times I had heard that during my more than two decades in the media world. It allows Caucasians off the hook so they can justify not hiring a minority for a position. Dreher doesn’t need to look at the numbers to know whether news rooms have become less diverse, he simply has to take a stroll around his own newsroom.

  • http://none FitzRoy campbell

    Well said Roland. You gave us all a clinic on the importance of jornalism how it should be . Getn out of our comfort zone and communicate with every ethnic back ground. Its easy for people like him to distort the truth. Hes not looing to report facts, for this is not what he is about.His calling is drama, and Rus linbraw type of white is right seft rightous jornalism. Once again you read wrote and erased him. Keep up the good work Roland . Thanks for caring the torch.

  • http://RolandMartin OBAMAGIRL

    Thank You Roland. Please continue to school these ignorant white folks! Bigots like Dreher are oblivious of the contributions that people of color bring to the world . He was brought up to believe that Minorities are inferior to him, we must eradicate such thoughts and practices from the likes of Dreher and his croonies. “Ethnic Diversity” is here to Stay, so Dreher better wake the hell up and deal with it!

  • http://www.tradebit.com/filedetail.php/32071304-talks-on-talking Leigh

    greetings, I can’t find your contact information but your web design layout looked rearranged on firefox and IE. Anyways, i just suscribd to your rss.

More from the Roland S. Martin Blog

  • Politics Washington Watch Rep. Clyburn Pushes The Clyburn Amendment To Help The Poorest Of The Poor (VIDEO)

    Rep. Clyburn Pushes The Clyburn Amendment To Help The Poorest Of The Poor (VIDEO)

    Rep. James Clyburn joined Roland Martin on the set of Washington Watch to discuss the Clyburn Amendment. This amendment was created to help the poorest of the poor across the United States. MR. MARTIN:  Is there anything specific the President and Congress can do to target African-Americans when it comes to this high unemployment number? REP. CLYBURN:  Yes, there is, and we – you’ll find it in the rule development part of the so-called “stimulus bill.”  I- — was – [...]

    Read more →
  • News

    WASHINGTON WATCH: Rep. James Clyburn On Feb. Job Numbers, African-American Unemployment, Bipartisan Jobs Bill (VIDEO)

    New employment numbers came out Friday showing the economy continues to recover and continues to add jobs at a pretty healthy pace. There were 233,000 private-sector jobs created in February. That’s two, solid years of private-sector job growth. The unemployment rate was steady at 8.3 percent. Black unemployment was 14.1 percent, up half a percentage point from last month. Big job gains came in healthcare, business and professional services, as well as restaurants. The jobs problem and the upcoming election [...]

    Read more →
  • Commentary Sports ROLAND S. MARTIN: Props To NCAA For Banning Connecticut From March Madness

    ROLAND S. MARTIN: Props To NCAA For Banning Connecticut From March Madness

      By Roland S. Martin Editor-in-Chief RolandMartinReports.com March Madness is usually a wild and crazy time on the campuses of the nation’s big-time college basketball programs as fans wait in line for days for tickets to see their favorite collegiate do battle in the NCAA postseason tournament. But if you’re a Connecticut Huskie fan, you’d better hope your team can have a magical run in the Big East tourney and qualify for an automatic bid because when it’s time for [...]

    Read more →
  • Media Politics Roland Martin On CNN Video Getting To The Polls: Is There An Enthusiasm Gap Amongst Republican And Democratic Voters?

    Getting To The Polls: Is There An Enthusiasm Gap Amongst Republican And Democratic Voters?

    Donna Brazile, Roland Martin, Ari Fleischer, Erick Erickson, Jessica Yellen and Anderson Cooper analyze voter turn out and if there is an enthusiasm gap amongst the GOP and Democrats. Sphere: Related Content

    Read more →
  • Media Politics Roland Martin On CNN Video Gingrich Has Problems With Women Voters, They Don’t Trust Him (VIDEO)

    Gingrich Has Problems With Women Voters, They Don’t Trust Him (VIDEO)

    Roland Martin, Erick Erickson, Donna Brazile, Ari Fleischer and Anderson Cooper discuss Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich, their wives and Gingrich’s problems with women voters.

    Read more →
  • Commentary Sports ROLAND S. MARTIN: Football Power In Texas Has Shifted To Houston

    ROLAND S. MARTIN: Football Power In Texas Has Shifted To Houston

    By Roland S. Martin Editor-in-Chief RolandMartinReports.com I hate the Dallas Cowboys. No, I don’t dislike them. I flat out cannot stand anything about the Dallas Cowboys. The year they went 1-15, I was ticked they won that one game. When they played in those three Super Bowls in the ’90s, I rooted hard for the opposition. Hell, I hate them more than the Ku Klux Klan! That’s why I take great pleasure in seeing the transfer of power in the [...]

    Read more →
  • Politics Herman Cain Tops Mitt Romney In Latest CBS/NYT Poll

    Herman Cain Tops Mitt Romney In Latest CBS/NYT Poll

    Source: Corbett B. Daly / CBS News CBS News Poll analysis by the CBS News Polling Unit: Sarah Dutton, Jennifer De Pinto, Fred Backus and Anthony Salvanto. Businessman Herman Cain is now atop the field of Republican White House hopefuls, squeaking past former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney in the latest CBS News/New York Times poll. Cain garnered 25 percent support of Republican primary voters in the poll released on Tuesday, compared to Romney’s 21 percent. To read this article in its entirety [...]

    Read more →
  • Politics Rick Perry: Obama Birth Certificate ‘A Good Issue To Keep Alive’

    Rick Perry: Obama Birth Certificate ‘A Good Issue To Keep Alive’

    Source: Luke Johnson / The Huffington Post Texas Gov. Rick Perry said the birther issue was worth “keeping alive” in a CNBC interview Tuesday morning. “It’s a good issue to keep alive. It’s fun to poke at him,” said Perry, according to host John Harwood. Perry also spoke evasively about President Barack Obama’s birth certificate in an interview with Parademagazine published over the weekend. When asked if he believed the president was born in the United States, he said, “I have no reason to think [...]

    Read more →
  • Video What Did You Think Of The GOP Debate? (VIDEO)

    What Did You Think Of The GOP Debate? (VIDEO)

    CNN’s T.J. Holmes caught up with some folks just after the Las Vegas GOP debate ended. WATCH: Sphere: Related Content

    Read more →
  • Video Poverty Rises For Blacks In Omaha (VIDEO)

    Poverty Rises For Blacks In Omaha (VIDEO)

    CNN’s Thelma Gutierrez reports on the disproportionate rate of poverty among African-Americans in Omaha, Nebraska. WATCH: Sphere: Related Content

    Read more →