You are here: Home » News »

Judge Tosses Suit Against Obama Health Care Plan

02/23/2011 7:54 am 0 comments

Washington — A federal judge on Tuesday threw out a lawsuit claiming that President Barack Obama’s requirement that all Americans have health insurance violates the religious freedom of those who rely on God to protect them.

U.S. District Judge Gladys Kessler in Washington dismissed a lawsuit filed by the American Center for Law and Justice, a Christian legal group founded by evangelist Pat Robertson, on behalf of five Americans who can afford health insurance but have chosen for years not to buy it.

The case was one of several lawsuits filed against Obama’s requirement that Americans either buy health insurance or pay a penalty, beginning in 2014. Kessler is the third Democratic-appointed judge to dismiss a challenge, while two Republican-appointed judges have ruled part or all of the law unconstitutional. Kessler wrote that the Supreme Court will need to settle the constitutional issues.

Three of the plaintiffs — Margaret Peggy Lee Mead of Hillsborough, N.C., Charles Edward Lee of San Antonio and Susan Seven-Sky of West Harrison, N.Y. — are Christians who said they want to refuse all medical services for the rest of their lives because they believe God will heal their afflictions. They say being forced to buy insurance would conflict with their faith because they believe doing so would indicate they need “a backup plan and (are) not really sure whether God will, in fact, provide,” the lawsuit said.

To read this article in its entirety visit MSNBC.

Sphere: Related Content

Bill Clinton: GOP Argument On Taxing Wealthy Americans ‘An Insult To Those People’ (VIDEO)

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy Source: AP / The Huffington Post Washington — Former President ...

President Obama Proposes $1.5 Trillion In New Taxes (VIDEO)

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy Source: MSNBC Washington — President Barack Obama, setting up another ...

MSNBC: Despite Red flags, White House Gave $500 million To Failed Solar Company

Source: Martin Wolk / MSNBC The Obama administration committed more than $500 million in taxpayer money to a maker of solar ...

FINANCIAL TIMES: President Obama To Propose Medicare And Medicaid Cuts

Source: Stephanie Kirchgaessner and James Politi in Washington / Financial Times Barack Obama is expected to lay out a plan next ...

USDA To Ban Six New E. Coli Strains From Meat Supply

Source: JoNel Aleccia / MSNBC Federal agriculture officials are expanding long-delayed rules that will ban six new strains of potentially lethal ...

President Obama: Jobs Plan Will Block Double-Dip Recession

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy Source: David Jackson / USA Today President Obama has a ...

Appeals Court Favors Obama Health Care Law

Source: David Jackson / USA Today President Obama wins the latest round in the health care legal fight. A federal appeals court ...

Obama Cancels Ozone Rules After Lobbying By Business

Source: Mark Drajem / Bloomberg President Barack Obama quashed proposed rules on ozone from the Environmental Protection Agency, agreeing with Republicans ...

President Obama Set To Deliver September 7 Economic Address To Congress

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy Source: CNN Washington - President Barack Obama requested time Wednesday ...

Amputated Penis Leads To Lawsuit Against Doctor

Source: AP / MSNBC Shelbyville, Ky. — The dispute between a Kentucky man and a surgeon over the necessity of amputating ...

Bill Clinton: GOP Argument On Taxing Wealthy Americans

President Obama Proposes $1.5 Trillion In New Taxes

MSNBC: Despite Red flags, White House Gave $500

FINANCIAL TIMES: President Obama To Propose Medicare And

USDA To Ban Six New E. Coli Strains

President Obama: Jobs Plan Will Block Double-Dip Recession

Appeals Court Favors Obama Health Care Law

Obama Cancels Ozone Rules After Lobbying By Business

President Obama Set To Deliver September 7 Economic

Amputated Penis Leads To Lawsuit Against Doctor

More from the Roland S. Martin Blog

Politics Washington Watch
Rep. Clyburn Pushes The Clyburn Amendment To Help The Poorest Of The Poor (VIDEO)

Rep. James Clyburn joined Roland Martin on the set of Washington Watch to discuss the Clyburn Amendment. This amendment was created to help the poorest of the poor across the United States. MR. MARTIN: Is there anything specific the President and Congress can do to target African-Americans when it comes to this high unemployment number? REP. CLYBURN: Yes, there is, and we – you’ll find it in the rule development part of the so-called “stimulus bill.” I- — was – [...]
Read more →
News
WASHINGTON WATCH: Rep. James Clyburn On Feb. Job Numbers, African-American Unemployment, Bipartisan Jobs Bill (VIDEO)

New employment numbers came out Friday showing the economy continues to recover and continues to add jobs at a pretty healthy pace. There were 233,000 private-sector jobs created in February. That’s two, solid years of private-sector job growth. The unemployment rate was steady at 8.3 percent. Black unemployment was 14.1 percent, up half a percentage point from last month. Big job gains came in healthcare, business and professional services, as well as restaurants. The jobs problem and the upcoming election [...]
Read more →
Commentary Sports
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Props To NCAA For Banning Connecticut From March Madness

By Roland S. Martin Editor-in-Chief RolandMartinReports.com March Madness is usually a wild and crazy time on the campuses of the nation’s big-time college basketball programs as fans wait in line for days for tickets to see their favorite collegiate do battle in the NCAA postseason tournament. But if you’re a Connecticut Huskie fan, you’d better hope your team can have a magical run in the Big East tourney and qualify for an automatic bid because when it’s time for [...]
Read more →
Media Politics Roland Martin On CNN Video
Getting To The Polls: Is There An Enthusiasm Gap Amongst Republican And Democratic Voters?

Donna Brazile, Roland Martin, Ari Fleischer, Erick Erickson, Jessica Yellen and Anderson Cooper analyze voter turn out and if there is an enthusiasm gap amongst the GOP and Democrats. Sphere: Related Content
Read more →
Media Politics Roland Martin On CNN Video
Gingrich Has Problems With Women Voters, They Don’t Trust Him (VIDEO)

Roland Martin, Erick Erickson, Donna Brazile, Ari Fleischer and Anderson Cooper discuss Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich, their wives and Gingrich’s problems with women voters.
Read more →
Commentary Sports
ROLAND S. MARTIN: Football Power In Texas Has Shifted To Houston

By Roland S. Martin Editor-in-Chief RolandMartinReports.com I hate the Dallas Cowboys. No, I don’t dislike them. I flat out cannot stand anything about the Dallas Cowboys. The year they went 1-15, I was ticked they won that one game. When they played in those three Super Bowls in the ’90s, I rooted hard for the opposition. Hell, I hate them more than the Ku Klux Klan! That’s why I take great pleasure in seeing the transfer of power in the [...]
Read more →
Politics
Herman Cain Tops Mitt Romney In Latest CBS/NYT Poll

Source: Corbett B. Daly / CBS News CBS News Poll analysis by the CBS News Polling Unit: Sarah Dutton, Jennifer De Pinto, Fred Backus and Anthony Salvanto. Businessman Herman Cain is now atop the field of Republican White House hopefuls, squeaking past former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney in the latest CBS News/New York Times poll. Cain garnered 25 percent support of Republican primary voters in the poll released on Tuesday, compared to Romney’s 21 percent. To read this article in its entirety [...]
Read more →
Politics
Rick Perry: Obama Birth Certificate ‘A Good Issue To Keep Alive’

Source: Luke Johnson / The Huffington Post Texas Gov. Rick Perry said the birther issue was worth “keeping alive” in a CNBC interview Tuesday morning. “It’s a good issue to keep alive. It’s fun to poke at him,” said Perry, according to host John Harwood. Perry also spoke evasively about President Barack Obama’s birth certificate in an interview with Parademagazine published over the weekend. When asked if he believed the president was born in the United States, he said, “I have no reason to think [...]
Read more →
Video
What Did You Think Of The GOP Debate? (VIDEO)

CNN’s T.J. Holmes caught up with some folks just after the Las Vegas GOP debate ended. WATCH: Sphere: Related Content
Read more →
Video
Poverty Rises For Blacks In Omaha (VIDEO)

CNN’s Thelma Gutierrez reports on the disproportionate rate of poverty among African-Americans in Omaha, Nebraska. WATCH: Sphere: Related Content
Read more →

← previous next →

Trending On RolandSMartin.com

More from the Roland S. Martin Blog